12 Cool Ice Cream Shoppes in Wisconsin Competing for Best Ice Cream Shoppe in 2025

August 25, 2025
2273
Discover , Polls , Vote for Nominees
Comments Off on 12 Cool Ice Cream Shoppes in Wisconsin Competing for Best Ice Cream Shoppe in 2025

Wisconsin is known for cheese, beer, and of course — amazing ice cream. From old-fashioned custard stands to trendy artisan scoop shops, the Badger State is full of frozen treasures. This year, Found In Wisconsin is shining a spotlight on 12 of the state’s coolest ice cream destinations, each competing for the title of Best Ice Cream Shoppe in Wisconsin for a 2025 WI Heart Award.

What makes the WI Heart Awards so special? Unlike other awards, these are 90% nominated and voted on by the people of Wisconsin with just 10% input from the Found In Wisconsin staff. That means the voice of the people truly matters — and your favorite shoppe could take home the crown.

Here are the 12 ice cream shoppes you can vote for in 2025:

1. Adrian’s Frozen Custard – Burlington, WI

A local legend since 1974, Adrian’s serves up rich, creamy custard that has kept generations coming back. Known for their turtle sundaes and rotating flavors of the day, it’s a true custard classic.

2. Belts’ Soft Serve – Stevens Point, WI

Home of the giant cones, Belts’ is a Stevens Point tradition. Their portions are as legendary as their long lines on warm summer nights.

3. Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream – Madison, WI

With flavors like “This $&@! Just Got Serious” and “Zanzibar Chocolate,” this Madison staple is as bold as it is delicious. They’re famous statewide for their quirky, rich, and indulgent flavors.

4. Divino Gelato Cafe – Waukesha, WI

A taste of Italy in downtown Waukesha, Divino Gelato is known for handcrafted gelato and sorbet, made fresh daily with authentic recipes.

5. Door County Ice Cream Factory – Sister Bay, WI

A Door County favorite where cherry is the star, this shop makes ice cream from scratch and serves it in fresh, homemade waffle cones. Perfect after a day on the peninsula.

6. Kelley Country Creamery – Fond du Lac, WI

Often called “the best ice cream in America,” Kelley’s makes small-batch ice cream right on their fifth-generation dairy farm. Over 300 flavors have been created here — talk about variety!

7. Purple Door Ice Cream – Milwaukee, WI

This artisan creamery uses local ingredients to craft creative flavors like Brandy Old Fashioned, Whiskey, and Earl Grey. It’s a go-to for Milwaukee ice cream lovers.

8. Sassy Cow Creamery – Columbus, WI

A family-run creamery with both traditional and organic dairy, Sassy Cow offers wholesome ice cream flavors served right on the farm. It’s a true farm-to-cone experience.

9. Scoop DeVille – Hartford, WI

Scoop DeVille mixes retro charm with inventive creations. Their sundaes and old-fashioned sodas make it a fun stop for the whole family.

10. South Pier Parlor – Sheboygan, WI

Famous for towering ice cream creations and inventive shakes, South Pier Parlor is where indulgence meets Instagram-worthy presentation.

11. The Windmill Ice Cream Shoppe – Tomahawk, WI

Located in a historic windmill, this shop offers a one-of-a-kind Northwoods experience with classic scoops and plenty of nostalgia.

12. Wilson’s Ice Cream – Ephraim, WI

A Door County institution since 1906, Wilson’s is known for its old-fashioned soda fountain, red-and-white awnings, and rich, homemade ice cream.

Vote for Your Favorite in the 2025 WI Heart Awards

Each of these ice cream shoppes represents the best of Wisconsin — from custard to gelato, classic cones to adventurous flavors. Now, it’s up to YOU to decide which one deserves the title of Best Ice Cream Shoppe in Wisconsin 2025.

The WI Heart Awards are powered by the people, and your vote makes all the difference. Whether you’re loyal to your hometown favorite or you’ve traveled the state in search of the ultimate scoop, your opinion counts.

👉 Cast your vote for your favorite ice cream shoppe in Wisconsin and help crown the winner of the 2025 WI Heart Award! You can vote once a day for your favorite. Voting ends September 30th, 2025 and the winner will be announced the first week in October.

12 Cool Ice Cream Shoppes in Wisconsin Competing for Best Ice Cream Shoppe in 2025